Best Sellers
BANANA PUDDING
Inspired by the Old Mill Restaurant favorite, this creamy scoop blends banana and vanilla wafer flavor in every bite.
OATMILL CREAM PIE
Our most-loved flavor, packed with chunks of our signature oatmeal cream pies for a rich, nostalgic bite.
WHISKEY RIBBON
A creamy base with a smooth whiskey-infused swirl, made with spirits from Old Forge Distillery.
