blog| menus   hours | newsletter |

Salt Water Taffy


Item   WEB-BT

The secret to lighter and chewier taffy is in the pulling and stretching of the boiled sugar mixture. And our soft and flavorful taffy is authentically pulled by vintage 1930's taffy crank machines! You can watch our candymakers right there in the Old Mill Candy Kitchen, first boiling sugar and other pure ingredients in old-fashioned copper kettles, then rolling and stretching the taffy to soft, chewy, fruity sweetness.

Average of 5 customer reviews:      Write a Review

Tupelo, MS
May 2014


How Long Have You Been Using This Product: More than 2 years

This is the best taffy I have ever had! I love that you can come into the store and select your own taffy as much or as little as you like in any flavor. My husband and I make special trips to Pigeon Forge just to get this taffy. Flavors are spot on. Yummy!

Huntsville, AL
August 2014

salt water taffy

How Long Have You Been Using This Product: Less than 1 month

loved the taffy!!!! delicious and so many flavors. My favorite is the peanut butter log!

Kansas City, MO
October 2014


How Long Have You Been Using This Product: More than 2 years

I always come home with about 5lbs. of taffy each year when I visit. This taffy is the best...the taste is spot on, the freshness is outstanding and the employees of all Old Mill shops is top notch. I look forward to this trip every year.

August 2017

Best Taffy Ever

Age Range: 35-44
Gender: female

I love this taffy. Its flavoring is spot on and its not hard like other salt water taffies I have had. So many flavors to pick from and they are all delicious.

You might also like