If you've ever tasted a bite of The Old Mill Restaurant's famous pecan pie, you will understand why we put the pie into a mix that you can bake anytime you are ready. You'll be amazed the homemade taste! Each jar makes one 9-inch pie.
Make it your own by adding 1/2 cup each of 1-2 of these ingredients: chocolate chips, chopped Candy Kitchen Bear Paws or Sea Salt Bears, sweetened flaked coconut.
Average of 5 customer reviews:
Write a Review
Rain
Louisiana
September 2013
pecan pie mix
How Long Have You Been Using This Product: More than 2 years
I really like this mix. It is easy and taste great. The best way for me to make a pecan pie and my father loves them. I will keep on making them for him as long as I can get the mix.
jotum
Knoxville
September 2013
Best Pecan Pie
How Long Have You Been Using This Product: More than 2 years
We visited the restaurant and loved the pecan pie. Found the mix at the store and have bought a bunch over the last few years. It makes the same delicious pie. We make it for company especially from the north to show them a good southern pecan pie. They all rave about it. Just returned from our second trip to Pigeon Forge specifically to get the pie mix and they were out both times. Sure do hope they have it next time.
cyndi
canada
September 2013
pecan pie mix
How Long Have You Been Using This Product: Less than 1 month
yummy, absolutely yummy
stacyb
Conway, SC
December 2013
Best Pecan Pie
How Long Have You Been Using This Product: Less than 1 month
This makes the best pecan pie. I love to bake and usually stay away from mixes but decided to give the Pecan Pie Mix a try for Thanksgiving. The pie got wonderful reviews from everyone and my husband even told me it's the best pecan pie I have ever made. I agree. (I still haven't told him it began with a mix. :))
Pieman
Nashville, TN
April 2014
THE Best Pecan Pie EVER
Age Range: 55-64
Gender: male
How Long Have You Been Using This Product: 4-6 months
I'd never bought a "pie in a jar" so I thought I'd try this. It is THE BEST pecan pie I've ever eaten and that includes pies from a grandmother and great grandmother that baked from scratch. Unbelievable.
R. George
North Carolina
August 2014
Closest to homemade!!!
How Long Have You Been Using This Product: 4-6 months
This pecan pie mix is fabulous! All you need to do is add a couple of ingredients, pour into a pie shell and bake. Tastes just like a homemade pecan pie! My husband has asked now a few times for more of these easy, wonderful pies. I plan on stocking up some of these mixes for the holidays!
Blindmom
Fort Wayne, in
November 2014
Amazing!
How Long Have You Been Using This Product: Less than 1 month
So simple yet the taste was so amazing! I will definitely buy this again!
Martha Faye
Chattanooga , TN
December 2014
GREAT
How Long Have You Been Using This Product: More than 2 years
This is the only pecan pie receipe I will use, it is the best and is not as sweet as the receipe I have used in the past. it will make 2 small pies or 1 large deep dish pie. it is so easy quick and simple. Never again would I use any other kind.
Pecan Bill
Tennessee
February 2015
Best Pecan Pie You Ever Ate
How Long Have You Been Using This Product: More than 2 years
I brought a jar home from a trip to the Old Mill and was blown away by how good this was. My grandmother and great grandmother made great pecan pies from scratch. This rivals both of them. I ordered 6 jars for Thanksgiving and Christmas. Keep a couple of deep dish pie shells in the freezer and a pie is always an hour away.
Steph
Spartanburg SC
December 2017
Amazing!!
Age Range: 35-44
Gender: female
This is so easy but so very good!! You won’t be disappointed!!
Pecan Pie Bars: Preheat oven to 400°F. Unfold 1 sheet refrigerated pie crust; roll to 12-inch square and fit into 8-inch baking pan. Prick with fork and bake 10 minutes or until it appears dry; press edges to sides of pan with back of spoon. Reduce temperature to 350°F. Prepare pie mix as directed; pour into crust. Bake as directed. Cool before cutting into squares.
